BMI Screening in Mass Schools

  • posted by Marci Evans
  • Sunday, May 17, 2009

So it’s been over a month since The Boston Globe published an article“BMI screening will begin this fall in Mass. schools.” This topic has weighed heavily on my mind (yikes, no pun intended) but I still seem to be combing through all of my thoughts on the topic.

The article states that starting this fall public schools will begin weighing and measuring 1st, 4th, 7th, and 10th graders (parents can opt out) as a means to screen for overweight and obesity. The results, along with a report on how to deal with a child’s weight problem will be sent home to the parents. As I type, my blood is beginning to boil.

Here are a couple of thoughts:
1.) America has a pretty poor track record. As we’ve become more weight obsessed over the past several decades, the number of people that are overweight and obese has continued to climb.
2.) Research has shown that obesity prevention programs targeted to elementary and middle school children increased disordered eating behaviors.
3.) There is no utility in sending home a report card to a parent that says “your child is fat and at increased risk for Type II diabetes.” The article states that one of the recommendations for parents with overweight kids is to take them to their pediatrician. No offense to any pediatricians out there but I cannot help but laugh. I’d love to meet a physician that has the skills and more than 10 minutes solve their patient’s “weight problem.”

So rather than sending our children home with a report card, why don’t we start taking action that focuses on behaviors, not numbers. There is plenty of research to show that this is effective. Here are some ideas:
1.) Have students track the number of minutes they spend per day engaging in physical activity. And by all means, let’s stop cutting out recess and gym classes.
2.) Create a school garden. It will teach our children where food comes from, how to take stewardship over the earth, and supplement the pathetic meals they are served at school with more fruits and vegetables.
3.) Partner with local farms to facilitate work in exchange for reduced or free crops for low-income families.
There are a myriad of ways to promote healthy living. Sending report cards home is not one of them. With a Department of Health staffed with intelligent and capable people, I’d like to think we can do better than that. (Sorry for the rant, I do try to keep them to a minimum.)



If you liked this post, you might also like one of these recent posts:

  1. Tips for Thanksgiving Marci Evans 22-Nov-2016
  2. Self-Care or Self-Destruction Post-Election 2016 Marci Evans 15-Nov-2016
  3. #TBT: Serving Size vs Portion Size Marci Evans 08-Nov-2016
  4. Calories, Calories Marci Evans 01-Nov-2016
  5. Body Positive & Weight Loss Marci Evans 27-Oct-2016
  6. Dare to be Different Marci Evans 25-Oct-2016
  7. How to Help Someone with an Eating Disorder Marci Evans 08-Oct-2016
  8. The Role of the RD: Outpatient Eating Disorder Treatment Marci Evans 02-Oct-2016
  9. The Weight of Weight Stigma Marci Evans 26-Sep-2016
  10. Falling in Like with Exercise Marci Evans 19-Sep-2016
Comments
Liz commented on 20-May-2009 04:39 PM
I imagine that most parents know whether they child is overweight or not, just by looking at them. It seems crazy that the state of Massachusetts is going to spend time and money on something so pointless (but I suppose that is something that governments do best...) I wholeheartedly agree with your suggestions to focus on proper eating behaviors. Overweight kids are likely not getting that at home, so at least they could learn things like that at school!

Post a Comment




Captcha Image

Trackback Link
http://www.marcird.com/BlogRetrieve.aspx?BlogID=2459&PostID=64718&A=Trackback
Trackbacks
Post has no trackbacks.

Related posts:

Part II: What to Buy (Nutrition)

Saturday, March 07, 2009
Last week I introduced the topic of grocery shopping. I covered the first part (preparation) in a five-part series. Today I’d to talk a little bit about nutrition. Nutrition is a very controversial topic. Why? Because the science behind it is complicated! Case in point: fat. You’ve likely heard a litany of recommendations on fat intake; eat a low fat diet for heart health, decrease your saturated fat, avoid trans fat like the plague, increase your monounsaturated fats, decrease belly fat ...

The Feeding Relationship: Parents & Children

Sunday, March 15, 2009
I just got back from serving on a health panel at my church here in Cambridge.  I thoroughly enjoyed talking about my topic of choice (food and nutrition) for two hours.  While there was a wide variety of questions that I addressed, a common theme focused on the feeding relationship between parents and children.  While my practice focuses primarily on adult nutrition, I have been amazed to see how our grown-up feelings, attitudes, and behaviors about food stem from our interact...

Eating by the Season- Asparagus

Tuesday, April 14, 2009
Eating food that is in season is one of the best things you can do for your health and your local economy.  Produce that is in season tends to be higher in nutritional quality and available for purchase from your local farmers markets...soon to be sprouting up! Here is a link to a fabulous resource from the website Field to Plate.  It's a page with a link to seasonal produce by State.  And about.com  has a great article with a list of fruits and vegetables along with their peak growing sea...

Boston Marathon: A spirit of motivation

Monday, April 20, 2009
As I type, the Boston Marathon is well underway.  Since 1897, thousands of athletes have trained rigorously in order to compete in the world's oldest annual marathon race.  And it is a site to behold!  Last year, I cheered on runners at mile 22.  With a few miles to go, some competitors were running, some were walking, and some were even limping.  As I stood there I thought "while this is truly amazing, long distance running is not for me!"  And I would imagine that many of you feel the s...